Skip to main content

Chapter 2 - Rules for Strangers

At 11:43 PM, Caify Khan made a decision.

She would not message Kabir407 first.

It was a perfectly reasonable decision, she told herself.

She had work to finish, messages to answer, and an entire life that existed independently of a man whose real name she didn't even know.

Besides, he had been the one to send the first message last night.

There was no reason she should always be available.

She put her phone face down on the bed and opened her laptop.

For the next seven minutes, she concentrated on her work.

Then she turned the phone over.

Nothing.

She returned to her laptop.

Another five minutes passed.

She checked again.

Still nothing.

"Ya Allah," she muttered, closing her eyes. "Mujhe isse koi farq nahi padta."

She had said it aloud.

That was embarrassing enough.

She opened the audio-chat application.

Kabir407 was online.

Caify stared at the green indicator beside his username.

She could send him a message. There was no rule against it.

She simply didn't want him to think she had been waiting.

She typed:

So, Mr. Respectable Citizen, aaj duniya bachane ka plan hai ya aaram karoge?

She read the message.

Deleted it.

Typed another.

Online ho?

Deleted that, too.

Finally, she sent:

AK26: I have a question.

The reply came almost immediately.

Kabir407: That's how all dangerous stories begin.

Caify smiled.

AK26: Tumhare paas har baat ka jawab hota hai?

Kabir407: Nahi. Kuch log bahut sawaal poochte hain.

AK26: Toh mat diya karo jawab.

Kabir407: Phir tum poochna band kar do.

She shook her head.

"Pagal aadmi."

Her phone began to ring.

Kabir was calling.

She answered before the second ring.

"Ji, boliye."

"Madam, aapne question poochne ki permission di thi. Call karne ki nahi."

Caify laughed.

"Tumne hi call kiya hai!"

"Details matter."

"Achha, toh suno. Aaj se kuch rules honge."

Kabir leaned back in his chair.

"Rules?"

"Haan. Rules for strangers."

He glanced at the time.

It was 11:51 PM.

He should have been finishing his work.

Instead, he found himself saying, "Theek hai. Batao."

Caify sat cross-legged on her bed, suddenly pleased with herself.

"Rule number one. Real names nahi poochne."

"Agreed."

"Rule number two. Personal details nahi poochne."

"Define personal details."

"Jaise address, family ka naam, phone number—"

"Phone number toh hum exchange kar chuke hain."

Caify stopped.

There was a short silence.

"Rule number two kal se apply hoga," she declared.

Kabir laughed.

"Very convenient."

"Rule number three. Agar kisi din baat karne ka mann nahi hai, toh clearly bol dena. Ghost nahi karna."

This time, Kabir didn't respond immediately.

The sentence was ordinary enough. People said things like that all the time.

But something about it stayed with him.

He had spent years becoming comfortable with unexplained absences. He understood that there were circumstances in which a person could not give an explanation.

He had rarely considered how those absences felt to the person left waiting.

"Fair enough," he said.

Caify heard the change in his voice.

"Problem?"

"Nahi."

"Tumne itni jaldi agree kar liya. Suspicious lag raha hai."

"Main ek achha insaan hoon."

"Proof?"

"Abhi tak tumse baat kar raha hoon."

She laughed.

"That proves nothing."

"Fine. Rule number four?"

She pretended to think.

"Rule number four. No flirting."

Kabir looked at the screen.

Then he laughed so suddenly that Caify began laughing, too.

"Kya hua?" she demanded.

"Kuch nahi."

"Toh hans kyun rahe ho?"

"Bas, rule number four bahut interesting hai."

"Interesting kya hai?"

"Jo insaan khud raat ko message kare, woh flirting se bachne ka rule bana raha hai."

Caify's smile disappeared.

Only for a second.

"Excuse me. Main tumhe message isliye karti hoon kyunki tum entertaining ho."

"Of course."

"Don't flatter yourself."

"Main toh bilkul nahi kar raha."

"Good."

"Very good."

They fell silent.

Then Caify asked, "Waise, tumne aaj dinner mein kya khaya?"

Kabir looked at the empty plate beside his laptop.

"Food."

She groaned.

"You're impossible!"

"Question hi galat tha."

"Achha, Mr. Intelligence—"

She stopped.

Kabir's fingers went still on the desk.

"What?"

Caify laughed.

"Mr. Intelligence! Har baat ka jawab, har baat mein logic. Tum scientist ho kya?"

Kabir relaxed.

"Something like that."

"Something like that matlab?"

"Matlab main scientist nahi hoon."

"Thank you, Sherlock."

He smiled, but he didn't answer the question she had almost asked.

Caify moved on.

For now.

The things people tell strangers

Over the following week, their conversations developed a rhythm.

They spoke at night, sometimes for twenty minutes, sometimes for two hours. They exchanged messages during the day whenever their schedules allowed it.

They learned small things about each other.

Caify hated people who interrupted her in the middle of a story.

Kabir disliked unnecessary drama but somehow found himself participating in it whenever she was involved.

She loved asking questions.

He loved pretending he wasn't interested in answering them.

She could turn a minor inconvenience into a ten-minute complaint.

He could respond to that complaint with one sentence that made her laugh despite herself.

They also began noticing things that neither had consciously decided to remember.

Kabir learned that Caify often said she was fine before explaining why she wasn't.

Caify learned that Kabir sometimes went quiet when a conversation became personal.

Neither mentioned these observations.

They simply adjusted to each other.

One night, Caify was telling him about an argument she had witnessed earlier that day.

"And then she said that she had done absolutely nothing wrong," Caify continued. "Can you imagine? She had literally started the entire argument."

Kabir was quiet.

"Hello?"

"I'm listening."

"Then say something."

"What do you want me to say?"

"Anything!"

"Anything."

Caify stared at her phone.

For three seconds, she was speechless.

Then she burst out laughing.

"You're such an idiot!"

"You asked for anything."

"I hate you."

"That seems excessive."

She was still laughing when she replied.

"No, seriously. Tumse baat karke mera dimaag kharab ho jayega."

Kabir smiled.

"Then why do you keep calling?"

The question escaped him before he had thought about it.

Caify stopped laughing.

It was a simple question, delivered casually.

Yet it seemed to demand a more honest answer than either of them had prepared to give.

She looked at the ceiling.

"Pata nahi," she said finally. "Tumse baat karna achha lagta hai."

Kabir looked at his phone.

He could have made a joke.

He could have said that the feeling was mutual.

Instead, he said, "Achha hai."

Caify frowned.

"Bas? Achha hai?"

"Kya bolun?"

"Kuch bhi. Rehne do."

He smiled faintly.

But after the call ended, he remained seated for a long time.

He replayed her words.

Tumse baat karna achha lagta hai.

It wasn't a confession.

It wasn't a promise.

It was barely even a statement.

Still, something inside him had shifted.

And that was precisely what made him uncomfortable.

Gwalior and Agra

On Friday night, the conversation took a different turn.

Caify had finished her work early. Kabir had returned home later than usual.

They began with their familiar arguments about music and movies.

Then Caify asked, "Tum Gwalior mein hi rehte ho?"

"Haan."

"Born and brought up?"

"Mostly."

"Mostly matlab?"

Kabir hesitated.

"I've travelled."

"Travelled kahan?"

"Different places."

She sighed dramatically.

"Ya Allah, tumhari biography likhne baithun toh pehle chapter mein hi author mar jayega."

Kabir laughed.

"Why do you want to know so much?"

Caify considered the question.

"Because I talk to you."

"And?"

"And if I'm talking to someone, I want to know something about them."

He was quiet.

She continued, more gently, "It doesn't mean I want your entire life story. Bas, thoda sa toh pata hona chahiye."

Kabir looked at the window.

He had a thousand ordinary things he could tell her. The school he had attended. The roads he remembered from childhood. The food his mother made when he came home late. The way Gwalior looked from certain places after rain.

Those details were harmless.

They were also personal.

He realised that he had become so accustomed to separating parts of his life that he sometimes treated even ordinary information as something to be withheld.

"I grew up in Gwalior," he said at last. "My family lives here. I've moved around a little because of work."

Caify smiled.

"See? Itna bhi mushkil nahi tha."

"Don't get used to it."

"Too late."

He asked her about Agra.

She told him about familiar roads, family gatherings, and the way a place could feel both comforting and restrictive depending on the day.

She spoke about home as a collection of people and habits rather than a building.

Kabir listened.

He did not ask her to describe herself in a few neat sentences. He let her wander from one memory to another.

Eventually, she asked, "Tum apni family ke close ho?"

Kabir's answer came after a pause.

"Haan."

"Good."

"Why?"

"Bas. Achha lagta hai jab koi apni family se connected hota hai."

He nodded, even though she couldn't see him.

Then she asked, "Tumhare ghar mein sabko pata hai ki tum raat ko strangers se baat karte ho?"

Kabir laughed.

"No."

"Good. Warna tumhari respectable citizen wali image khatam ho jaati."

"That would be a national tragedy."

"Bilkul."

For a moment, both were laughing.

Then Kabir's phone vibrated against the desk.

He glanced at the screen.

His expression changed.

Caify heard the silence.

"Again?"

Kabir looked at the notification.

"Just a work message."

"Okay."

"I may have to go."

"Fine."

He waited for her to say something else.

She didn't.

He had expected her to ask what had happened. Instead, she simply accepted his answer.

For some reason, that made him feel worse.

"AK?"

"Hmm?"

"Kal baat karenge."

"Sure."

The call ended.

Kabir opened the message.

It was brief, formal, and unrelated to anything he could discuss with her.

He read it twice.

Then he placed the phone face down.

For the first time in a long while, he found himself wishing that an ordinary conversation could have continued without interruption.

The rule about disappearing

The next evening, Kabir didn't appear online.

At first, Caify didn't notice.

She was busy with her own work. She spoke to a friend, replied to messages, and spent time with her family.

At 11:30 PM, she opened the application.

Kabir407 was offline.

She closed it.

At midnight, she checked again.

Still offline.

She told herself it meant nothing.

They had never agreed to speak every day. They were not in a relationship. She did not owe him her attention, and he did not owe her his.

She repeated these arguments until they began to sound convincing.

At 12:17 AM, a message arrived.

Kabir407: Sorry. Got caught up with work.

Caify read it.

She was relieved.

Then, almost immediately, she became annoyed with herself for being relieved.

AK26: It's okay.

She put the phone down.

A minute later, another message arrived.

Kabir407: You're awake?

AK26: Unfortunately.

Kabir407: Should I call?

Caify stared at the screen.

The question was simple.

It was also the first time he had asked rather than assumed.

She replied.

AK26: Haan. Call kar lo.

The phone rang.

"Hello," Kabir said.

"Hello."

There was a short silence.

"You're angry," he said.

Caify raised her eyebrows.

"Wow. Intelligence training?"

"Your voice changed."

"My voice is the same."

"Okay."

"Okay."

He waited.

She waited.

Finally, Kabir sighed.

"Sorry. I should have told you earlier that I might be unavailable."

Caify looked at the wall.

She hadn't expected him to say that.

"It's fine," she replied, though her voice softened. "You don't have to explain everything."

"I know."

"Bas, agar nahi aa sakte, toh bata diya karo."

"I'll try."

She was about to respond when he added, "I mean it."

For some reason, that mattered.

Not because she believed he would never disappear again.

Because he had listened to what she was actually asking.

"Okay," she said quietly.

They talked for another hour.

Before ending the call, Caify reminded him of their rules.

"No ghosting."

"No ghosting," he agreed.

"No pretending to be a respectable citizen when you're clearly an idiot."

"That rule seems unnecessarily personal."

"It's important."

He laughed.

"Goodnight, AK."

"Goodnight, Kabir."

After the call ended, Caify stared at the screen for a moment.

Then she put the phone away.

She did not know that the promise he had made would eventually become one of the hardest promises of his life.

And Kabir did not yet understand that the rules they had invented as a joke would one day become the measure by which Caify judged him.

The name behind the number

Three nights later, Caify finally asked the question she had been avoiding.

They had been talking about school, old friends, and the embarrassment of childhood photographs.

Kabir had admitted that he had once been caught sleeping during a class.

Caify refused to believe him.

"Tum? Class mein sote the?"

"Yes."

"Impossible."

"Why?"

"Tum toh aise behave karte ho jaise bachpan mein bhi tumhare paas five-year strategic plan raha hoga."

Kabir laughed.

"Unfortunately, I was once a child."

"Proof?"

"Birth certificate bhejun?"

She laughed so hard that she had to move the phone away from her face.

Then, when she had recovered, she asked, "Waise, Kabir407... tumhara actual naam kya hai?"

The laughter faded.

Kabir looked at the screen.

He had known the question would come eventually.

He had expected it to feel like a threat.

Instead, it felt strangely ordinary.

"My name is Kabir," he said.

"Bas Kabir?"

"Kabir Sharma."

Caify repeated the name softly.

"Kabir Sharma."

Hearing it from her made it feel different.

Not more important, exactly.

More real.

She smiled.

"Achha naam hai."

"Thank you. Main khud choose nahi kar sakta tha."

"Phir bhi credit le rahe ho?"

"Obviously."

She laughed.

Then she asked, "Toh Sharma ji, ab main bhi apna naam bataun?"

Kabir sat quietly.

"You don't have to."

"I know."

She paused.

Then she said, "Caify."

He repeated it.

"Caify."

There was a moment of silence.

Not the uncomfortable kind.

The kind that follows a small revelation when both people understand that something has changed.

"Nice to meet you, Caify," he said.

She smiled at the phone.

"Nice to meet you too, Kabir Sharma."

Neither mentioned that they had already spent hours getting to know each other.

Neither acknowledged that a name could make a stranger feel closer.

For the first time, they had exchanged something that could not be reduced to a username.

They had given each other a little more of the truth.

And, for that night, it was enough.

A message at 1:06 AM

The following week, Kabir was working at his desk when a message appeared.

AK26: Can I ask you something serious?

He stopped typing.

Kabir407: Depends on how serious.

AK26: Properly serious. No jokes.

He looked at the message for a moment.

Then he replied.

Kabir407: Okay. Ask.

There was a pause.

Longer than usual.

Then:

AK26: Do you ever feel lonely even when you're surrounded by people?

Kabir read the question once.

Then again.

Outside, a vehicle passed through the wet street, its headlights briefly illuminating the room.

He could have offered a reassuring answer.

He could have said that everyone felt lonely sometimes.

Instead, he typed:

Kabir407: Yes. More often than I admit.

Caify read the message.

She did not respond immediately.

Then:

AK26: Same.

Two words.

No jokes. No teasing. No attempt to turn the conversation into something lighter.

Kabir looked at them for a long time.

He had spent years learning to tolerate loneliness without naming it. He had learned to fill silence with work, routine, and responsibility.

Now, a woman in another city had asked a simple question and made him answer honestly.

He opened the call screen.

Then he stopped.

He did not want to interrupt her.

Instead, he sent another message.

Kabir407: Want to talk?

Her reply arrived.

AK26: Haan.

He called.

When she answered, neither spoke for several seconds.

Finally, Caify said, "Kabir?"

"Hmm?"

"Thank you for answering honestly."

He looked down at his hands.

"You're welcome."

She took a breath.

"Main bhi kabhi-kabhi bahut lonely feel karti hoon. Even when everything is fine."

Kabir listened.

She told him about the strange exhaustion of being expected to manage everything, the difficulty of explaining certain feelings, and the embarrassment of admitting that she sometimes wanted someone to ask whether she was genuinely okay.

He did not interrupt.

He did not offer solutions.

When she finished, he said, "I understand."

Caify was quiet.

"Really?"

"I don't know if I understand everything. But I understand what you're saying."

For the first time that night, she felt no need to make a joke.

"That's enough," she whispered.

They stayed on the call until nearly two in the morning.

They spoke about loneliness, childhood, expectations, and the things they wanted from life.

Neither made a promise.

Neither confessed love.

But when they finally said goodnight, the silence that followed was different from the silence they had known before.

It was no longer entirely empty.

At 2:14 AM, Kabir placed his phone beside his notebook.

He had work to finish.

There were responsibilities he could not ignore and questions that required his attention.

Yet before returning to them, he opened the conversation one last time.

Caify's final message was still on the screen.

AK26: Goodnight, Kabir Sharma.

He smiled.

Then he locked his phone.

He did not know that the name he had given her would one day become a memory she would struggle to say aloud.

He did not know that she would eventually learn things about him that he had not yet learned how to explain.

He did not know that the woman who had begun as a stranger would become the person whose opinion mattered most to him.

For now, he knew only this:

He had started looking forward to their conversations.

And for a man who had spent years arranging his life around duty, that small admission was more frightening than he was prepared to acknowledge.

Popular posts from this blog

Aaj Aur Abhi Se

"Mohabbat agar wajah ban jaaye, toh insaan apni hadon se bhi aage nikal jaata hai." Kabhi socha hai ki mohabbat ka sabse khoobsurat izhaar kya hota hai? "I love you?" Ya phir, "Main tumhare liye chaand taare tod laaunga?" Mujhe nahi lagta. Mohabbat kabhi chaand-taaron ki mohtaaj nahi hoti. Woh toh kisi ki aankhon mein apne liye fakhr dekhne ki chahat hoti hai. Woh kisi ki muskurahat ke liye khud ko behtar bana lene ka naam hoti hai. Woh kisi ke liye apni kamiyon se ladne ki himmat hoti hai. Aur shayad isi liye, is kahaani ki shuruaat bhi ek bahut chhote se sawaal se hui thi. "Mere liye kya kar sakte ho?" Caify ne yeh sawaal bahut saadgi se poocha tha. Shayad mazaak mein. Shayad sach mein. Aur shayad usse khud bhi nahi pata tha ki uske is chhote se sawaal ka jawab Kabir ki poori zindagi ki disha badal dega. Kabir chup tha. Woh hamesha se aisa hi tha. Kam bolne wala. Har baat ko mehsoos karne wala. Waade karne se pehle sau baar sochne wala. Usse jh...

I May Not Have the Cure, But I’ll Make Your Pain Half

Maana har dard ki dawa na hai hum, Par tere gham ko aadha kar denge. Zakhm jo diye hain kisi ne, Hum usko bhar denge. There are some promises that do not claim to solve everything. They simply promise presence. This poem begins with such a promise. It does not say, “I will make everything perfect.” It says, “I may not have the medicine for every pain, but I will not let you carry it alone.” And perhaps, sometimes, that is the most beautiful form of love. We often think that loving someone means protecting them from every sadness. We imagine that if we truly love someone, we should be able to remove their tears, erase their memories, and heal every wound they carry. But human beings do not possess such magic. We cannot rewrite another person's past. We cannot undo what someone else did. We can only choose to stand beside them while they slowly find their way back to themselves. “Maana har dard ki dawa na hai hum...” There is humility in these words. The speaker does not pretend to ...

One Day They'll Ask You To Leave Yourself Too...

"Babuji ne kaha gaon chhod do... sabne kaha Paro ko chhod do... Paro ne kaha sharaab chhod do... aaj tumne keh diya haveli chhod do... ek din aayega jab wo kahenge, duniya hi chhod do..." I think Devdas was never about alcohol. Neither was it about Paro. Devdas was a story about a man who was slowly being asked to leave everything he had ever loved... piece by piece... until there was nothing left to leave except himself. And sometimes... I wonder whether all of us become Devdas someday. Life has a strange habit of asking us to let go of things we never wanted to lose. First, it takes away our childhood. Then our innocence. Then the people we thought would stay forever. Slowly... very slowly... it keeps negotiating with our heart. It never asks for everything together. It would be too cruel if it did. So it takes one thing at a time. And the worst part is... after a certain point, we stop fighting. I remember someone once asking me, "Kabir, tum life me kya chahte ho?...